The National Story: a case study of an IBC transaction

Aerial view of the National Steel and Agro Industries plant

Chances are you probably don’t read a lot of positive content on the internet. It’s not (entirely) your fault though: humans have a strong “negativity bias.” It’s not a new phenomenon either. This knowledge has been exploited by news and media organisations for a very long time. Of course, the exponential growth of social media platforms and widespread internet access means raw exposure to negativity is growing at a terrifying rate.

The stressed asset and insolvency space in India is not immune to negative press either. We tried a simple Google search for “IBC success.” There was no positive search result; instead we found this towards the top:

India’s Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code is not working; here’s what’s going on

Business Today, 27 July 2023

The article itself is eye-opening and informative, with objective analysis of raw data (here’s the link (opens in a new tab) to the full story; it’s definitely worth a read).

The success of India’s Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code is not written about enough. Through our lens as a support entity in the successful resolution of National Steel and Agro Industries Limited, this is a content-heavy and comprehensive case study of a remarkable success story we are proud to be a part of.

The phrase “the proof is in the pudding” is an abridged version of the original: “the proof of the pudding is in the eating,” which begins to make more sense. To put it succinctly, judgment should be reserved until one has direct experience. And that brings us to the primary objective of this case study: a glimpse into the real world of IBC through the lens of an Insolvency Professional.

Join us in taking a bite out of this pudding. The pudding is baked perfectly well, but if your goal is to be the best pudding in the world, you will need to do a bit more work! The good news is that the regulator’s actions and approach suggest that is the eventual target: to be recognised globally as best-in-class. The journey won’t be easy, but IBC is definitely “trending upward.”

Alright, on to the case study.

Transaction summary

Admitted claims
₹2,400 cr
Liquidation value
₹330 cr
Resolution plan value
₹620 cr
Resolution plan approved by the CoC
Day 179
Annualised turnover
₹400 cr
Employees and workmen
1,200
EBITDA swing (−2% to 9% annualised)
11%
Capacity utilisation
96%
Interim finance raised
None

National Steel and Agro Industries Limited (“NSAIL”) was a public limited company and a Fortune 500 listed company in India. Primarily known for its flat steel products, the Company also had an agriculture vertical. NSAIL’s insolvency commencement date was 11 April 2022, when our Group Chairman, Mr. Dushyant C Dave, was appointed as the Insolvency Professional. Mr. Dave appointed his support entity (group company and IBBI registered IPE M/s. Decode Resolvency International Private Limited) and took charge by deploying a dedicated team with local presence at the site in Indore, as well as resources at NSAIL’s head office in Mumbai.

Within 45 days, the Company reversed its negative EBITDA and started showing signs of revival. The JSW Group played a key role in keeping the Company afloat and running as a going concern in the years preceding insolvency by entering into a “job work” arrangement with NSAIL. The plant was operational with skeletal leadership and a lack of efficient, skilled management as on 11 April 2022. Apart from JSW job work, the Company also manufactured goods for other customers, either directly through sale mechanisms or through job work with other parties, to maximise production.

The impact of the short-term measures we undertook was immediate and tangible. The Company reversed its downward-trending EBITDA from negative $0.19M in March 2022 to positive EBITDA of $0.244M within 60 days. These numbers improved a further 330% (3.3x) within the first 90 days. By around 100 days, NSAIL had recorded EBITDA of $0.645M and PBT of $0.17M. Other medium-term measures (3–9 months) had a direct impact on the bottom line. The cost of goods sold fell by 4% over 8 months, and EBITDA margins rose from −2% in April 2022 to 12% in January 2023. Overall production increased by about 58% during our tenure, and current assets grew from $0.3M to about $2M over the same period.

In IBC, the common approach is that the Board of Directors does not have any role since its powers are suspended. However, there is another key aspect to this law: while the powers are suspended, they are also to be exercised by the Insolvency Professional. Hence, the Board is not dissolved; only its powers are suspended and exercised by the Insolvency Professional.

In a first, Mr. Dave promoted a Senior Vice President and inducted a new member to the Board, while also appointing him as the designated Factory Occupier. This proved extremely effective in raising employee morale, improving productivity and establishing rapport with all employees. It also ensured accountability and responsibility within the organisation.

To build confidence among all stakeholders, meetings were organised with vendors, clients, KMPs, HR and all department heads. Strained relationships were mended where that was in the Company’s interest, and new relationships were forged where required. Appointing trained, seasoned people with the right network in the steel industry was crucial to this process.

These numbers were achieved in spite of a sudden change in government policy: in May 2022, within the first 45 days of our tenure, the export duty on the Company’s products went from 0% to 15%. To put the impact in perspective, exports declined by more than 50% year on year, and by July 2022 India had become a net importer of steel instead of a net exporter. Prices of the products the Company made fell by around 30%. Companies going through insolvency usually need interim financing because of credit cycles and the state of vendor relationships. This Company was run successfully as a going concern at close to 100% capacity without raising any interim finance.

By the 179th day, a resolution plan submitted by a wholly owned subsidiary of the JSW Group (a $25B conglomerate whose subsidiary is India’s largest manufacturer in the Company’s industry) had been tabled and approved by the Committee of Creditors. The total plan value was about ₹620 crore, equivalent to 180% of the Company’s liquidation value. By keeping the Company running at close to 100% capacity throughout the insolvency proceedings, Mr. Dave and his team helped maximise value for the creditors’ committee, with payments to secured creditors, unsecured creditors and all employees and workmen made in an equitable and fair manner.

Setting the stage

Aerial view of the National Steel and Agro Industries plant beside the Mhow–Neemuch road
The NSAIL plant on the Mhow–Neemuch road, from the drone footage made during the process.

NSAIL’s corporate insolvency resolution process commenced on 11 April 2022. Apart from the roles and duties prescribed in law, we prioritised making a drone video of the plant. We highly recommend informative videos with text overlays, flows and asset overviews that are easy to share. To maximise value in stressed asset transactions, it is important to be a great salesperson! When pictures say a thousand words, a video can show a million pictures. These aren’t easy to create, and a lot of work goes on behind the scenes, but it is absolutely worth it.

The reality is that this should be the norm on a basic cost-benefit analysis. If asset inspection is limited to static content and site visits, you have probably not cast the net wide enough. Not every eligible buyer can schedule a site visit before a first round of filtering.

A video will ensure your assets do not slip through a potential buyer’s first elimination round, which significantly improves your conversion ratio.

When the time came to publish Form G, inviting potential resolution applicants to submit their interest, we were ready with a set of investor material that helped us hit the ground running: a one-pager, email cascades, an information memorandum, the video, trained on-site personnel available at short notice for site visits, and training for department heads on the communication skills needed when meeting potential buyers.

Business is personal. A video and a process are a great starting point for personal connections with buyers.

Transaction timeline: a resolution plan approved on day 179

The entire NSAIL CIRP was conducted as per the model timeline prescribed in law. Insolvency Professionals have 180 days from the date of commencement to file an approved resolution plan with the Adjudicating Authority, the Honourable National Company Law Tribunal (“NCLT”).

Most of the concerns about the success of IBC revolve around the fact that it takes “too long.” However, this is a matter of expectation management, not a judgment on the law itself. How should one decide what is “too long”? Everyone who practises insolvency (who has “eaten the pudding”) knows that the 180-day window is an aggressive timeline. In 2015, before IBC, the average time for resolution was 4.3 years. By 2019, within three years, it had already improved significantly because of IBC, to 1.6 years. An Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (“IBBI”) research paper in 2021 cites a World Bank statistic:

However, we still have a long way to go as the best regulatory performance in resolving insolvencies is 0.4 years (Ireland).

So it is clear that IBC is reducing the resolution period. Now the aim is to improve further, with the Ireland benchmark in our sights. With the NSAIL CIRP, we met all of the timelines thanks to a true team effort by numerous stakeholders. Here are the key dates alongside the model timeline:

ActivityModel timeline
days after T
Actual
days after T
Insolvency commencement dateTT
Public announcement inviting claims32
List of creditors filed with IBBI2121
Report certifying the constitution of the CoC filed with NCLT2323
Notice for the first CoC meeting2525
New GST registration3029
First meeting of the CoC3030
Resolution to appoint the RP by the CoC3037
Appointment of valuer4746
RP forms an opinion on preferential and other transactions7570
Information memorandum submitted to the CoC5451
Form G published7567
Expressions of interest submitted by potential resolution applicants9084
Final list of resolution applicants issued by the RP115101
Request for resolution plans issued, with evaluation matrix and IM105100
Resolution plans received (after negotiation and one revision)135178
CoC-approved resolution plan submitted to the Adjudicating Authority under Regulation 39(4)165179

The facts of every case are different, and some delays are beyond the Insolvency Professional’s control. However, some innovation, done in good faith, can truly change the game in an assignment. There is a surprisingly limited amount of dialogue around soft skills that cannot be prescribed or taught; they must come from experience and from a resolution-driven mindset.

If Insolvency Professionals had additional tools in their box, such as conflict management, negotiation, team building, human capital, stakeholder communication and behavioural psychology, perhaps they would not need to resort to the tried-and-tested litigation route every time they faced a problem. IPs often err on the side of caution because each decision carries significant accountability, and a legal opinion or order validates it. Of course, there are times when legal remedies are the best course of action and we cannot over-generalise, but the point still stands: litigation should be a last resort.

This is also why there is now a push towards arbitration and mediation. A high-performing team takes effort. It needs ownership of, and buy-in to, a common goal among all stakeholders. With NSAIL, we were lucky to be guided and driven by large, reputable organisations such as the JSW Group and JM Financial, with seasoned professionals in the team. That aspect must not be taken lightly: the right people, involved at the right time and in the right way, are crucial to the success of such a transaction. For various reasons, many creditor committee meetings are not fruitful, and that leads to inordinate delays. Everyone involved needs a common goal at a high level (a successful resolution) and at a granular level (such as targets for each CoC meeting).

Summary of steps taken

Necessary steps were taken to improve the efficiency of the equipment, and in January 2023, during the insolvency proceedings, the company produced 30,165 metric tons of hot rolled coils, the highest in its 30-year history.

Here are some of the steps and actions taken over the course of the CIRP:

  • Deployment of an eight-person interim management team.
  • Revamped security protocols and systems.
  • Asset preservation: tagging, tracing, regular physical verification, timely renewal of insurance, maintenance and planned shutdowns to avoid unacceptable wear and tear, renewal of expiring trademarks, analysis of the value of intangible assets, and identifying gaps in the IT framework and data.
  • Revised purchase and sales policies to improve credit cycles and maximise proceeds from the sale of goods.
  • An e-auction platform for the sale of products, to increase transparency and create competition.
  • Creation, modification and adherence to SOPs, with buy-in and ownership from the relevant functional heads and departments.
  • Lower inventory holding costs, by selling all saleable products in a timely manner.
  • Monitoring of production and dispatch through daily MIS and variance analysis.
  • A robust process for maintaining and monitoring the Company’s costing records, to understand product-wise profitability.
  • Dedicated legal and compliance officers as an integral part of the interim management.
  • Recovery of dues using ageing analysis, with different strategies depending on the amount receivable and the party concerned.
  • Liaison with government and regulatory authorities, which needed effective negotiation and people with the right skills to achieve a good outcome.
  • Marketing and sales: a revamped structure and a buyer onboarding process, with sale strategies designed to increase competition and maximise proceeds.
  • A concurrent audit system to monitor production and cash flows.
  • HR: the function was weak, so the HR team was given additional support and regular training. Incentive programmes were reinstated to lift engagement and morale.
  • Purchasing: vendor selection, RFQ and negotiation policies were revised and payment terms renegotiated. Vendors that had stopped supplying the Company were approached with a clear message that all their dues were protected and would be paid in full.
  • Plant hygiene, cleanliness and beautification work, completed successfully.
  • Safety made a priority, with the necessary training and communication.
  • Quality: product quality improved and the rejection rate from customers fell significantly.
  • Occasions, cultural activities and celebrations for the well-being of employees and labourers continued throughout.
  • Regular feedback and surveys, including one-to-ones with every person on the Company’s payroll.

Avoiding avoidance

An Insolvency Professional must report “avoidance transactions” if any are found to have taken place in the preceding months (such as preferential, undervalued, fraudulent or extortionate transactions). We identified one such transaction, where a payment had been made to a related party of the Company. Under the law, the Insolvency Professional may apply to the Honourable NCLT for directions, and the court has the power to reverse a transaction. However, that would take significant time and resources and delay the process. Since reversing the transaction was the best-case outcome, we chose to start a dialogue between the Company’s promoters and the related party. These efforts, with crucial support and cooperation from the erstwhile management and promoters, led to the entire payment being reversed and returned to NSAIL.

Resolution plan specifics

Some salient points of the resolution plan:

  • Total plan value of about $80M, a total recovery to the creditors’ committee of 180% of the Company’s liquidation value.
  • A commitment to infuse about $3M of additional capital for short-term use, to de-bottleneck capital expenditure.
  • Payment of all insolvency process costs in full and in priority.
  • Payment to all operational creditors higher than they would have realised had the Company been liquidated. To support MSMEs and other operational creditors, these payments were proposed in priority to the secured financial creditors.
  • Information on how the Company’s affairs will be managed after approval by the Adjudicating Authority, to ensure continuity and the prospect of remaining a going concern in the long term.
  • The existing issued, subscribed and paid-up equity share capital reduced entirely, without any consideration.
  • The Company to be merged with the subsidiary after delisting, capital reduction, loan conversions and extinguishing public shareholding.
  • A clean slate: all financial liabilities written off in full by the Adjudicating Authority’s order approving the plan.
  • The entire plan to be implemented within 30 days of approval by the Adjudicating Authority.
  • Avoidance transaction proceedings able to continue in parallel, with any recoveries in the first two years going to the financial creditors.
  • A specific statement that the plan is unconditional, that the source of funds is defined (the JSW Group) and that the plan will not be modified after approval by the Adjudicating Authority.

While introducing better practices and systems, we focused throughout on the culture and working environment. The high-functioning team was noticed and remarked on positively by the CoC and by the successful resolution applicant. We also used the period between CoC approval and NCLT approval to coordinate across areas and make the transition smooth and quick.

Closing thoughts

It takes a village.

The transaction was also recognised by TMA, a global organisation for turnaround, as the best “Mid-Size Turnaround and Transaction of the Year” for 2023 (read more about the award).

Without cooperation from the promoters, active engagement from the CoC and a trained, dedicated team, under the stewardship of Mr. Dushyant C Dave and the JSW Group, this transaction would not have been a success.

If you are here, thank you for taking the time to read this success story of National Steel: “The National Story.”

This transaction reinforces the idea that resolving a company through the insolvency court depends heavily on the credibility and approach adopted. We were able to show that information symmetry and open dialogue are the key pillars of speedier resolutions. It helps the regulators and the government make the case that the model timeline is realistic and achievable.

Managing more than 1,100 employees and workmen with different backgrounds, identities, experiences and perspectives requires leadership that is sensitive and leads by example. The interim management and the Company’s leadership embraced diversity across the board, with key stakeholders and managers of different ages, ethnicities, religions, regions and expertise. All decisions were based on factual data, with no sign of bias or preference. In the few instances where exclusionary conduct was observed, we chose to educate and retrain the people involved, helping them recognise their biases in real time and decide objectively.

We encouraged respectful dialogue and listened actively to different perspectives. That helped us resolve ground-level problems amicably and gain the confidence of all stakeholders. We tried to make sure everyone in the Company felt valued, respected and empowered to contribute to the team’s success.

The different expertise and diversity we brought as a team let us do justice to the project. We tried to lead by example in fostering open communication, while training teams not to avoid conflict. We helped mediate differences by focusing on the problem and driving constructive change. We also helped teams understand that, in projects like this, they need to operate and thrive in uncertain environments.

We look forward to tremendous growth in the sequel to The National Story, now part of the JSW family.

Not sure which business is right for you? Start with us.

The first conversation is a 30-minute call. Tell us what you are facing and we will bring the right people.